Homeschooling     Hot Topics     Home and Family     K-12     Education Guide    

Are we really ready to send kids back to school?

Teachers’ union demands increased protection for students and staff

schools, teachers, unions, students, parents

School districts around the country are struggling to balance COVID-19 risks against the emotional and academic impact of kids' not being able to attend school in person. The hybrid model, which includes both in-person schooling and remote learning, is assumed to be the best compromise. But this is an area the teachers' union claims that more work needs to be done before schools are ready to confront the increased risk of having kids spend half their schooling time outside the classroom.

Variations on the hybrid model depend on the resources of the school district. In many cases, younger children and those with particular needs are offered full-time in-person classes. Older kids tend to get one or two days a week in person and the rest of the time remote. 

In an open letter to the school communities in Orange, Westchester, Putnam, and Rockland Counties, the leaders of teacher and staff unions allege that government support for school re-entry has been insufficient and the New York State guidelines are not stringent enough. They outline a number of measures to make the schools more resistant to spreading COVID-19:

1. Filtration of all building-wide HVAC systems should be upgraded or supplemented with portable units equipped with HEPA filtration.

2. COVID testing will not be adequate unless reliable results are available within 24 hours. The current wait time of up to 12 days will be ineffective to prevent and monitor asymptomatic spread of COVID. 

3. PPE supply lines should be prioritized to maintain a supply of such items as masks, gloves, and sanitizer on hand at all schools.

4. Employment issues must be addressed. School districts must ensure employment of enough staff to supervise and instruct students, even when staff members are absent for illness, quarantine, child-care, or personal leaves.

5. A 100% virtual option must be available for teachers and students who are medically compromised.

Plans should require at least a 14-day shutdown if COVID issues require school closure.

The union letter cites an article in Wired magazine, in which Harvard epidemiologist William Hanage observed that under the hybrid model, the three or four days a week spent out of school will increase the potential contacts with people carrying the virus and thereby increase the potential of bringing it into the schools. Full-time in-person schooling, with reduced social distancing, might be actually be safer than the hybrid model, as the pool of contacts will be smaller and more consistent. None of the experts contributing to the article were aware of any studies done on European countries that implemented the hybrid model in the spring.

More Homeschooling

  • Visit cool sculpture parks in the Hudson Valley

    These sculptures are generally huge and sure to please

    Visit fun and educational sculpture gardens in the Hudson Valley. Sculpture Parks and their gardens are a unique way for families to appreciate and enjoy art. The open spaces are wonderful for kids of all ages. Most locations offer space to roam and enable us to enjoy these unique pieces at our own pace. read more »
  • Indoor spots for teens to play

    Older kids need to have some play time too

    Teens need places to go that aren't lame and won't bore them to tears. We have the best in the Valley listed just for you. read more »
  • Everything you need to know about student loans

    Traditional ways of paying for college aren't working

    More American families are borrowing for college. At the same time, merit aid and the use of personal income and savings i falling. read more »
  • 3 ways people of all ages can make the most of International Youth Day

    Celebrate youth activists and combat ageism

    August 12 is International Youth Day, a United Nations effort to celebrate youth activists, combat ageism and help bridge gaps between generations working toward the same change. read more »
  • Everything you should to know about student loans

    Traditional ways of paying for college aren't working

    More American families are borrowing for college. At the same time, merit aid and the use of personal income and savings i falling. read more »
  • 4 ways to get involved this global volunteer month

    It's a good time to get in on the action

    Global Volunteer Month, celebrated throughout April, is a time to recognize people who actively support their communities through volunteerism and active civic engagement. It’s also a time to get in on the action. However, if you’re like many people, you may not know where to begin. read more »
  • Minimize the risk of child identity theft

    NYS Division of Consumer Protection offers advice

    Child Identity Theft is a growing problem. According to recent data from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), identity theft for those under 19 years old grew 60% in three years. read more »
  • 5 reasons why your child should (and can) learn how to play chess

    A revolutionary new game that helps kids learn this game of strategy

    Chess is one of the oldest and most popular games in history, with early forms of the game dating back to the 6th century CE. The game has certainly seen a revival since the pandemic began, as people around the globe have dusted off their chess boards and even binged one of the most-watched series ever inspired by the masterful game for much-needed entertainment. read more »
  • 5 ways to get kids excited about STEM learning

    The country needs more good scientists

    The events of the past couple of years have shown how important scientists are to making the world a better and safer place. read more »
  • Keep kids learning during summer

    3 fun, easy ways

    With school out, summertime brings long, carefree days of play and fun. With a little thought and a few supplies, summer is a perfect opportunity to revitalize their innate love of learning that may be a bit squashed after a year of academic pressures, tests and schedules. read more »